BenQ ScreenBar Plus vs e-Reading Lamp: Which Wins?
This article contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
The dimension that actually decides this
This comparison comes down to one thing: where the light source lives relative to your eyes and your screen. Monitor light bars and desk lamps aren't just different form factors — they represent fundamentally different philosophies about how task lighting should be positioned. Get the positioning wrong and you're either washing out your screen with glare or leaving half your desk in shadow.
Most buyers in this category are working at a monitor-centric desk. If that's you, read the ScreenBar Plus section first and skip to the decision framework. If you work at a large drawing surface, read desk, or routinely work away from your screen, keep reading through to the e-Reading section.
BenQ ScreenBar Plus
The ScreenBar Plus is BenQ's top-tier monitor light bar. It clips to the top bezel of your monitor and aims a precisely shaped light beam downward onto your desk surface — not at your eyes, not at your screen. The asymmetric optical design is the key spec: the lens is engineered to direct light forward and down, which is what prevents screen reflection. That's not marketing language; it's a measurable beam geometry. Published expert reviews consistently confirm this design eliminates the monitor wash-out problem that plagues desktop lamps placed at the wrong angle.
The "Plus" suffix over the standard ScreenBar gets you a wireless dial controller that sits on your desk, so you're not reaching up to tap a bar mounted above eye level. Owner reports flag this as genuinely useful day-to-day. The dial handles color temperature (2700K–6500K range) and brightness without requiring you to memorize touch zones.
BenQ e-Reading LED Desk Lamp
The e-Reading is a freestanding desk lamp built for wide, even illumination across a large work surface. It sits on a weighted base, swings on an articulated arm, and covers considerably more lateral surface area than a monitor-mounted bar can reach. The 5-level color temperature range and stepless dimming are controlled via a touch panel on the base.
This is where the positioning question gets real. A desk lamp introduces a light source that your eyes can see directly — and if it's placed even slightly wrong (too far back, too close to the screen), glare on the monitor becomes a problem the ScreenBar physically cannot have. Owner reports on Amazon and Reddit suggest experienced users solve this by positioning the lamp to the side and angling it carefully, but it requires deliberate setup. At $249, you're paying a significant premium for that flexibility.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
Glare control
The ScreenBar Plus wins this dimension outright, and it's not close. Its asymmetric optics are purpose-built to prevent screen reflections. The e-Reading lamp can be positioned to avoid glare, but that depends on user setup. Across owner reports, complaints about screen glare appear significantly more often for freestanding lamps used at typical desk depths than for monitor-mounted bars. If glare-free viewing is the priority, the light bar has a structural advantage.
Desk footprint and cable management
The ScreenBar Plus occupies zero desk surface. It draws power via USB from your monitor (or a separate USB port), so there's one cable and no base eating up real estate. The e-Reading lamp requires a clear spot on your desk for its base — typically 6–8 inches of depth — plus a power cable run to the wall. For compact desks, this is a meaningful tradeoff. For large, deep desks, it's a non-issue.
Coverage area
This is where the e-Reading lamp genuinely earns its price premium — for the right user. A monitor light bar's beam is constrained by the width of your monitor (typically 24–34 inches) and focused on the near-desk zone directly below. If you're working on a wide drawing surface, referencing physical documents spread across a large desk, or frequently working away from your monitor, the lamp's broader, more adjustable beam covers ground the ScreenBar cannot.
Price-to-value
At roughly $139 vs. $249, the ScreenBar Plus costs 44% less. For the majority of monitor-centric desk setups, it solves the task-lighting problem more completely. The e-Reading lamp's extra $110 buys positioning flexibility and wider coverage — legitimate value if you need it, wasted spend if you don't.
At a Glance
| BenQ ScreenBar Plus | BenQ e-Reading LED Desk Lamp | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical price | ~$139 | ~$249 |
| Form factor | Monitor-mounted bar | Freestanding lamp |
| Color temperature range | 2700K–6500K | 2700K–6500K |
| Desk footprint | None (monitor-mounted) | Base + arm (~6–8 in. depth) |
| Glare-on-screen risk | Eliminated by design | Depends on positioning |
| Coverage area | Monitor width, near-desk zone | Wider, adjustable beam |
| Controls | Wireless desk dial | Touch panel on base |
| Amazon rating | 4.7★ (5,376 reviews) | 4.6★ (577 reviews) |
| $/star (derived value metric) | ~$29.57 per star | ~$54.13 per star |
The $/star metric is a rough proxy for price-to-satisfaction ratio, computed from typical list price ÷ star rating. Lower is better. ScreenBar Plus delivers nearly twice the satisfaction per dollar spent based on this metric — and its rating pool is nearly 10× larger, making it statistically more reliable.
Which One Is Right for You?
Buy the BenQ ScreenBar Plus if you work primarily at a monitor, have limited desk space, want zero-setup glare control, or simply don't want to spend $249 on a desk lamp. This covers the vast majority of remote-worker setups.
Buy the BenQ e-Reading LED Desk Lamp if you work across a large, deep desk surface, frequently reference physical documents spread wide, or your workflow doesn't center on a monitor — think architects, illustrators, or heavy paper-based readers.
Skip both if your desk is a standing setup used at arm's length, or if overhead ambient lighting in your room is already well-diffused — in either case, look at a dedicated ceiling panel or bias lighting strip before adding another task light.
Bottom line
For most remote workers with a monitor on their desk, the BenQ ScreenBar Plus is the correct answer. It eliminates glare by design, takes up no desk space, and costs $110 less than the alternative. The BenQ e-Reading LED Desk Lamp is genuinely good hardware — but it only justifies its price if your work surface and workflow actually demand what a freestanding, wide-coverage lamp provides. Buy for your real desk, not the one in the product photo.